Top of main content
 Couple using tablet; image used for HSBC Singapore Active vs passive investing article page.

Active vs passive investing: which strategy is right for you?

In the world of investing, there isn't just one set path you have to take. There are different styles, methods and options for investing. The path you choose should be a reflection of what you hope to get out of your investment, your ultimate financial goals, your risk appetite and exactly how involved you'd like to be on a day-to-day basis.

Essentially, there are 2 different styles of investing - active investing and passive investing. Let's take a look at the characteristics of each style of investing and the pros and cons involved, so you'll be better equipped to decide whether an active investment strategy or passive investment strategy is the best fit for you.

What is active investing?

Active investing is exactly what it sounds like: you take a personal, hands-on approach with your investments, devoting regular time to research and seek out the exact investments you plan to sink your capital into.

This means you're constantly plugged in to what's going on in the macroeconomic environment and the specific markets you're investing in. You also need to be equipped with in-depth knowledge about the investment tools and channels you pick, as well as the opportunities that would give you the best returns possible.

Usually, being an active investor means your priority is on accelerating your returns by taking advantage of a deeper understanding and an active assessment of the markets. If you're confident about a particular stock's performance, you'll have an opinion on the 'right' time to invest in it, so you can capitalise on market fluctuations and sweep up strong returns.

Naturally, with higher rewards also come higher risks, and it takes a certain level of confidence, investment experience and market savvy, as well as a lot of ground work to ensure your investments see more wins than losses.

What is passive investing?

On the other hand, passive investing is more of a more hands-off method than active investing. A hallmark trait of passive investing is that you're not the one constantly assessing or deep-diving into which specific investments to take up.

Rather than aiming to score big returns every time an opportunity arises, with passive investing, your focus is more on longer term gains. This also means your investments are meant to be held, and you wouldn't be letting go or buying in every time the markets show some movement.

Passive investing brings a fair degree of stability because you don't need to be losing sleep over every single stock you're holding due to market volatility or macroeconomic developments. Your ultimate goal is just to make sure your returns are in line with how market indices or a basket of stocks perform.

An example of this is investing in unit trusts, a type of investment fund where a pool of money is collected from investors and managed by a professional fund manager, who will use the funds to invest in a selection of diversified assets. Instead of having to personally monitor the performance of respective stocks and companies, you can depend on your fund manager to select suitable assets to include in the fund and regularly take stock of its performance on your behalf. Another passive investment tool is exchange traded funds (ETFs), which are baskets of securities from different companies that can be traded on the stock market. Unlike unit trusts, ETFs don't require active portfolio management as they involve index tracking through passive portfolio management.

Which investment method should you pick?

Now that you understand what active and passive investing involve, which one sounds best for you? To consider which method is more suitable for you, let's explore the pros and cons of each investing style.
Active investing
Passive investing

Pros

  • You're able to invest in exactly what you want and not have to take the direction of any index or basket of stocks.
  • You have the flexibility to cash in on investment opportunities you've identified as up and coming or even those that are a bit off the beaten track, but that you see as having great potential. You can also capitalise on market fluctuations and enter or exit the market whenever you think is best.
  • If you've done your homework and accurately assessed the market, your returns could potentially be higher.
  • You can hedge your investments using a variety of investing techniques and tools. Hedging helps you offset the risks of volatility and big swings in price movements.

    Cons

  • It potentially carries significantly higher risk than passive investing. Great risks could bring great rewards, but a wrong call on an investment could also lead to big losses.
  • It requires more effort on your part to actively research to identify investment opportunities.
  • Your capital is likely to be spread over fewer assets or holdings, which means less diversification and more exposure to the actual performance of any one stock or asset.
  • It's pricey, compared to investing in an index fund. With all the buying in you're doing every time you think an opportunity presents itself, transaction costs could really add up. Actively managed funds often carry higher management fees as well.

Pros

  • You're able to take a more hands-off approach to investing and not have to constantly monitor individual stock movement and trends.
  • If you're investing in a passive fund that is typically linked to a benchmark index, your investment will likely demonstrate more stability than if you were constantly cashing in and out on specific stocks.
  • It offers diversification to your investment portfolio, so your exposure is spread across several stocks or securities and you won't have to worry about the performance of any specific stock.


Cons

  • It's less flexible. You don't get to actively pick and choose stocks or holdings you might see great potential in, because you've got to stick to the variety the bundle provides.
  • Passive funds are linked to a benchmark index or pre-determined investments, so you won't see the huge returns that could potentially come with doing active investing. Your returns will largely mirror overall market returns.
Now that you understand what active and passive investing involve, which one sounds best for you? To consider which method is more suitable for you, let's explore the pros and cons of each investing style.
Active investing

Pros

  • You're able to invest in exactly what you want and not have to take the direction of any index or basket of stocks.
  • You have the flexibility to cash in on investment opportunities you've identified as up and coming or even those that are a bit off the beaten track, but that you see as having great potential. You can also capitalise on market fluctuations and enter or exit the market whenever you think is best.
  • If you've done your homework and accurately assessed the market, your returns could potentially be higher.
  • You can hedge your investments using a variety of investing techniques and tools. Hedging helps you offset the risks of volatility and big swings in price movements.

    Cons

  • It potentially carries significantly higher risk than passive investing. Great risks could bring great rewards, but a wrong call on an investment could also lead to big losses.
  • It requires more effort on your part to actively research to identify investment opportunities.
  • Your capital is likely to be spread over fewer assets or holdings, which means less diversification and more exposure to the actual performance of any one stock or asset.
  • It's pricey, compared to investing in an index fund. With all the buying in you're doing every time you think an opportunity presents itself, transaction costs could really add up. Actively managed funds often carry higher management fees as well.
Passive investing

Pros

  • You're able to take a more hands-off approach to investing and not have to constantly monitor individual stock movement and trends.
  • If you're investing in a passive fund that is typically linked to a benchmark index, your investment will likely demonstrate more stability than if you were constantly cashing in and out on specific stocks.
  • It offers diversification to your investment portfolio, so your exposure is spread across several stocks or securities and you won't have to worry about the performance of any specific stock.


Cons

  • It's less flexible. You don't get to actively pick and choose stocks or holdings you might see great potential in, because you've got to stick to the variety the bundle provides.
  • Passive funds are linked to a benchmark index or pre-determined investments, so you won't see the huge returns that could potentially come with doing active investing. Your returns will largely mirror overall market returns.

Before you decide...

You don't have to stick to just one strict style of investing. You could actually combine both active and passive investing and choose a mix of investment tools for your portfolio. The most important thing is to make sure you factor in your longer term financial goals, the length of time you want to be investing, your risk appetite and the level of involvement you want to exercise over your portfolio.

Ready to get started?

Learn more about different types of investment tools. Our wealth management articles are a good place to start.

Don't have an account yet? We can help get you started.

If you already have an investment account,

Listening to what you have to say about services matters to us. It's easy to share your ideas, stay informed and join the conversation.